Looking for a wonderful Shelter Island hotel? We’ve got you covered. From the guest rooms to water views, we’re rounding up exclusive offerings at Seven On Shelter Island. 

When you think about what you want out of a Shelter Island hotel, various visions spring to mind. You might appreciate nearby beach access. Or you’d like a lovely swimming pool. Maybe you’re jonesing for a beautiful view from every guest room, or a short jaunt to nearby Sag Harbor. We get it. Fortunately, we’ve done the work for you. We’re outlining all of the wonderful amenities, specifically at Seven on Shelter Island, that you’ll find at hotels on Shelter Island. While you’ll have your choice between larger resorts and smaller bed and breakfasts, Seven on Shelter Island has the trappings of a charming inn with the luxe offerings of a five-star hotel. 

Read on as we outline everything you need to know about Seven on Shelter Island – the best Shelter Island hotel you’ll find in this charming seaside enclave. Whether you’re seeking proximity to the ocean, or just a good book and some peace and quiet, you’ll have an unforgettable time on Shelter Island.

Why Shelter Island?

If you love the beach and a charming, slow-paced way of life, Shelter Island is for you. It’s got all the beauty of the nearby Hamptons, but it’s lowkey, easy, and filled with good vibes and good people. It’s got the best beaches on the East Coast, without the traffic or attitude. If you’re looking for an easy commute from New York or nearby cities, you should definitely visit a Shelter Island hotel. The island also has some of the best restaurants on Long Island, and there’s plenty to do both on and off the beach. The shopping is great and there are plenty of wineries nearby.

Where Does Shelter Island Get Its Name?

According to the Shelter Island Historical Society, the Manhanset Indians were the first to live on the island known as Manhansack Aha Quash A Womak, which translates to “Island Sheltered by Islands.” In 1620, King James I of England granted a large territory of land in North America, including Long Island and Shelter Island, to the Plymouth colonists. After the island changed hands, later to Stephen Goodyear of New Haven, it was sold as part of the Triangle Trade. Four sugar merchants purchased the island with 1,600 pounds of sugar. One of the merchants, Nathaniel Sylvester, married Grissel Brinley, and built their home on the Island. He settled here to run a farm that provided supplies for the sugar cane industry in the Caribbean. From this time on, the Island became known as “Shelter Island.”

Why Seven is the Best Hotel on the Island – The Amenities

Stylish & Luxurious Decor

The most stylish yet relaxed Shelter Island hotel is Seven on Shelter Island. Just steps from popular Crescent Beach, it’s got a charming “bed and breakfast” vibe with modern, upscale amenities you’d expect at a resort. The whitewashed farmhouse dates back to 1902 and was recently renovated by David Griffin, the celebrated interior designer, architect and Hamptons historian. Seven on Shelter Island owner Beth Swanström partnered with Griffin in evolving the space. Indeed, it has gone from a quiet, refined beachside inn to a luxury destination with art and design infused in every detail.

Inside, guests will be greeted by a stunning curation of art by Swanström, a former SoHo gallerist whose knack for contemporary art is on display throughout the hotel. The space features a series of works by Berlin artist: Sabine Dehnel, Marc Leavitt of Maine, Anne Lilly’s kinetic steel sculptures, and pieces by contemporary artist Billi Kidd.

Recreation & Relaxation

All you have to do is walk onto Seven’s hotel grounds to understand why it’s a great Shelter Island hotel. Outside, you’ll find a new, heated gunite pool flanked by a luxury cabana and custom outdoor pieces from Marcel Wanders’ Reverie collection in the form of black lattice lounge furniture with red accents. This collection is the first of its kind seen on the island. Just off the pool is an open air workout shed, with a cobalt blue enamel floor, free weights, a Peloton, MOMA water wheel rowing machines, Sonos Sound Bar, and large scale television for streaming workouts. Guests can work out freely or book private sessions with a licensed instructor who will join them at Seven.

Wellness & Meditation

The workout shed is also home to Seven on Shelter Island’s wellness offerings. There, guests can enjoy yoga classes – in both group and private sessions. There’s also meditation and breathwork, complete with tasteful moments at every turn. Guests can opt for sound healing baths with beautiful Tibetan bowls by Michelle Berlin, also known as Yogi Shelly, or enjoy a massage in the shed or out by the pool. The hotel also offers yoga and wellness retreats with Celine Antoine Yoga and many others throughout the fall and spring.

Luxury Accommodations

As far as the accommodations, both King and Queen rooms at Seven on Shelter feature luxe cotton linens, contemporary art, and sustainable bath products. by The Cold Spring Apothecary and Prè de Provence. With minimalist en suite bathrooms, flat screen televisions, and in-room refrigerators. There’s no end to comforts offered at Seven on Shelter Island. 

Bed & Breakfast

At Seven on Shelter Island, they spare no expense in offering French-inspired breakfasts. They serve French yogurts, fresh fruit, and bake bread every morning at the nearby Marie Eiffel café and market. Additionally, they can arrange for a mimosa if that is what you desire.

What’s The Perfect Day Like On Shelter Island?

Wake up and enjoy a beautiful breakfast at Seven on Shelter Island – either in the house, outside near the pool, or on one of its many patios. From there, take out a bike and cruise into town to check out the local bookstore or flea market. Stop at Marie Eiffel in town and grab goodies for your beach picnic lunch. Park your bike back at Seven and walk down to nearby Crescent Beach. Enjoy the people-watching at Sunset Beach and take a dip in the sound as the yachts make their way in for sunset. From there, it’s back to Seven on Shelter Island for a late afternoon swim, a cocktail or game of backgammon. Then it’s off to one of the many restaurants for a great night out on Shelter Island. Looking for some recommendations? This Shelter Island hotel has you covered.

FAQ

How do you get to Shelter Island?

Shelter Island is only accessible by car ferry. The North Ferry departs from Greenport, NY and the South Ferry from North Haven, NY. The ferries are operated by two separate companies, so be sure to check the schedules and ticket prices, as they are different. If taking the Long Island Railroad to Greenport, you can hop on the ferry from the train station.

Do you need a car on Shelter Island?

A car is beneficial for exploring the island, but  Shelter Island Taxi can also take you around the island.

Is Shelter Island dog friendly?

Extremely! We love our furry friends at Seven on Shelter Island, and a number of beaches, hiking trails and restaurants also cater to dogs. There’s also a veterinary clinic on the Island, and 24-emergency veterinary care is nearby.

What are some popular beaches on Shelter Island?

Shelter Island is flanked by gorgeous beaches with a gentle wave that’s perfect for families. We’re surrounded on all sides, so if you drive down any road, you’re likely to end up at a beach. Two public beaches, Wades Beach and Crescent Beach, have lifeguards (10 a.m. to 5 p.m. in season), designated swimming areas, picnic facilities and restrooms. Parking permits are required at these and most other beaches.

What if I’m in a medical emergency on Shelter Island?

To respond to medical emergencies, call 911 and provide your location to the operator. The Shelter Island EMS crew will dispatch immediately, and they will ready a ferry for transportation to an off-Island hospital, if needed. If necessary, the Suffolk County Police Department will provide medevac helicopter service to transport you to the region’s Level 1 Trauma Center at Stony Brook University.

Can I bring my bike to Shelter Island?

With its challenging hills, shady lanes and sprawling roads that all seem to lead to water, Shelter Island is a great place to ride. Use common sense and follow the rules for sharing the road to avoid conflict.

The Best Shelter Island Hotel with Your Desired Amenities and Accommodations

However you plan your journey, Shelter Island is a beach and nature lover’s paradise with endless things to do. You’ll have your choice of where to stay once you arrive. But, for those seeking luxury amenities fused with an intimate sensibility of an inn, look no further than Seven on Shelter Island. The staff and team at Seven will ensure you’ll have the trip of your life.